MAYBELLINEMaster Precise Skinny Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Sharp Brown, 1 Count

what i like about it: Easy to apply. wont't smudge, removes with soap and water, long lasting.What I dislike: easy to break off the tip if you advance it too much. Runs out quicker than pencil and these are hard to find in stores, so I buy them up in quanities whenever I see them, also , alittle pricey.

It goes on easily and smoothly which is important now that my eyelids are loose from aging. It makes a thin line I can build on and I like that it’s not liquid.

If you have purchased several eyeliners, trying to find ‘that one’, this is the one! Goes on easily, no pulling or tugging on delicate eyelids. Clean up with a Q-tip before it sets. STAYS PUT until you remove it. No sharpener is needed. This is a bargain purchase and one that I will have on repeat.

it will smudge if you rub it but i dont care.What's with all these industrial strength mascaras and liners now where you cant wash them off!i get water proof but it seems like everything is so harsh now. I used to love doing black liner but i never remembered it being this hard to take off!This product goes on smooth and is a great liner. i usually do liquid liner since it is easy to wash off. Now i can use a regular liner again!

I love the small size and smoothness of this liner. It's a nice dark line that will last the whole day. I gave it only 4 stars because the end does break off at times during application.

The best gel eyeliner I’ve used, especially as someone with dry eyes (that overreact & water profusely). I have trouble with most eyeliner in my waterline (& when I tight line), but this one stays in place all day without irritating my eyes.

What is up with this pencil?! Terrible. When I purchase it in store, it works like a charm; skinny, dark, and precise. I was excited to find it on Amazon, but the first time I purchased it, it wouldn’t mark on my skin, like barely at all. I thought maybe it was because it sat outside in the cold. Days later, it still didn’t work, I had to press so hard that it hurt my skin and it just crumbled apart and barely made a mark. I decided it must be a fluke so I ordered another - same thing happened, so this product has got to be an Amazon dud. I won’t ever order it again, only going to purchase it in store. Unfortunately, it’s hard to find in store.

I love my eyeliner to be thick and black, like my hair. This stuff is awesome. Goes on smooth, thick, dark, and dries pretty quickly. I also notice that it lasts much longer than my previous brand of eyeliner, even when I sweat or wipe my eyes. It doesn't smudge very bad either. Once it dries, it does flake a tiny bit, but not enough to be annoying. I'd definitely recommend.