Physicians Formula Organic Wear Lash-Boosting All Natural Mascara, Lifts, Lengthens, For Sensitive Eyes, Dermatologist Tested - Natural Origin Black

I was not at all sure about this when I first pulled it out of the box - the flat top, where you hold onto the wand felt weird and awkward the first couple times I used it. It only took a few tries to get used to, however, and the mascara is totally worth the effort!I have been very frustrated by "clean" mascaras (organic/all natural) because so few of them are actually dark! They tend to have a "natural" effect... i.e. they do very little of the volumizing or emphasizing of one's lashes that is so appealing in standard mascara! This one actually is an appreciably dark black, and adds both volume and emphasis. It takes more than one coat to the get look I want, but after two or three layers it looks just as good as the (sadly toxic) stuff I used to use.It does not irritate my eyes at all, and comes off completely cleanly and easily with a little bit of coconut oil. When smudged, it is also easily cleaned up and retouched.It DOES smudge - do not even think about rubbing your eyes or crying with this stuff on.I did not take off any stars for that, however, as it is apparently (and unfortunately) unavoidable in clean mascaras. Extensive reading of reviews for every mascara that gets safe ratings in the Skin Deep database sadly supports my own experience - easy smudge is just part of the price paid for not putting nasty chemicals near your eyes. *sigh*That said, as noted above, at least this mascara actually creates the look I have so missed being able to create and never irritates my eyes. Also, you can't beat the price! I was paying more than twice this much for another clean brand that smudged just as much and wasn't as dark.This is a good deal and a good product - definitely the best I've encountered so far, and I plan to stick with it!

I tried this because I'm supposed to wear falsies for dance gigs, but sometimes it's just not worth the trouble (& I liked the original formula too). So I use this & it's effective in giving the look of falsies with 2 layers.It'll clump with 2 layers & smudges even in about 1/2 hour before we start dancing (but moisturizing & no waterproof type claims anyhow).If you wear mascara just for daily use, 1 layer's plenty. Just have qtips or something around. I'll still use this before long-lasting stuff with chemicals.If I had my way I'd never even wear mascara, but removes easily with olive oil & my lashes feel healthy & fine.Choose the battle that suits your preferences& needs best I guess : )

I just wanted a little enhancement to my fine eyelashes and this product does just that. The ingredients are good. The only downside is that the mascara tends to flake a little and smudges with perspiration, etc.

Very disappointed with this product. When I received it and used for the first time, it seemed dried up and like not much product was on the wand. Then on the 3rd day of using it, the black insert around the top of the tube popped out and I could see inside the tube was almost completely empty. Only some product was at the bottom of the tub and came out so clumpy. I’ve used this brand before and really liked it, so not sure if this is just an old/expired product or if overall it has just become less quality than it used to be. But Definitely not planning on purchasing this again.

For a long time, Neutrogena Healthy Lengths mascara has been my go to, but of late, I can't get seem to get it, always OOS on line and in physical stores. I realize there are some supply chain issues, but I really needed to replace my mascara. I am not into paying a lot for mascara, as I find it is important to replace at least in a 3 month period for eye safety. So, I decided to try this product. So glad I did! I love the mascara wand-it is exactly like the wand in a sample of Dior mascara I got from Sephora. I loved that wand-mascara went on beautifully. So, when this wand appeared, I was sooo happy. This mascara is great. Goes on beautifully, and does NOT irritate my sensitive eyes. I am a contact lens wearer as well, and and it does not bother eyes with lenses in either. So glad I gave it a try, think it is a winner, and I am no longer saddy face about not finding the Neurtrogena product!

I really wanted to love this because of the clean, non-toxic formula, which is the main reason I bought it. Unfortunately, the results just weren’t what I hoped for.It tends to go on a little clumpy, and it doesn’t really give me the length or definition I get from some other mascaras I’ve tried. It’s okay for a very natural look, but if you’re looking for big lashes, this one probably isn’t it.The tube also never closed all the way, which made it dry out a lot faster than other mascaras as well. I do appreciate the non-toxic ingredients, but I’ll be trying a different brand next time.

I miss the formula that was offered prior to 2021; however, I have adjusted to this similar product. It does not smear even when it is a long and hot day. The formula does not have a strong scent which is a requirement for me. :) The mascara applies evenly and it's easy to tell when the bottle has run its course - the mascara will no longer apply evenly and leaves clumps.

I wanted to love this but just dont. It is very dry, at first I thought it was a bad item that I received but I had a replacement one sent to me and it is the same thing. It is all stuck to the very bottom very dry. As if it is old and no good. 2/2 were like this so I am thinking it is the product