JOAHMake Her Gel-ous Gel Eyeliner with Self-Sharpening Pencil, No-Tug Waterproof Formula & Long-Lasting Finish & Color Definition, Creamy Gel Texture, Black

This glides on nicely and has very nice/rich color. I had purchased based on a magazine review for its use on the waterline. Unfortunately, it did not last all day as I had hoped. But I will continue to use as regular liner.

I feel that it was a great value for what I paid for it and it was very easy to use

Goes on smoothly

Good product worth the price. Waterproof and stays on for hours

This pencil is easy to use, makes a clean line and looks great. It lasts for a long time and is easy to be smoothed for a softer line.

I like to smudge my eyeliner, then return with a soft black line near my eyelash- and this product is perfect for this application. Love it - and receive it regularly with a subscription!

Says it comes with a sharpener. I ordered more than one of these and none of them came with a sharpener. Ever though it's in the description and printed on the box. Would love to have a sharpener.

I like JOAH products. I especially like that every JOAH product I've purchased in stores and online has come with a great tamper proof seal.I bought this eyeliner in Black but it does not glide on. It is much too dry for me to use on my eyelid. I tried to make it work by using a smudger to smooth it out but that did not work. I don't like tugging at my eye area.I like the tip though, so I tried to use it on my eyebrows but it's too dark for that.